10 Awesome Homemade Cat Treats for Picky Cats

If you have a picky fur baby, you know how difficult it is to satisfy its taste buds – especially with homemade food. Perhaps, you often spoil your kitty with some toys and store-bought treats, but there’s something special in making your own edible surprises.

You don’t have to spend tons of time mixing and baking or have some special cooking skills. The following 10 homemade cat treats are incredibly simple and quick to make and you can store them in the fridge for up to a week.

Homemade Cat Treats From Wellness Mama

Believe it or not, many cats love coconut treats, but few owners know about it.

These homemade treats are made from coconut flour and contain coconut oil, making them drool worthy coconut cat treats. They also contain tuna and sweet potatoes – the two healthy ingredients that picky pets like as well.

Easy Frozen Banana Cat Treats From My 3 Little Kittens

Dogs aren’t the only ones who enjoy frozen banana treats, picky cats deserve these treats too.

Just ensure, you add a tiny bit of banana to your treats. The treats are superb and yummy, but not for cats that have throat-related problems, especially a sore throat.

Homemade Tuna Cat Treats From Supakit

Picky cats are sometimes not picky because they’re spoiled, but because they have different taste buds or they’re allergic to certain ingredients.

Since cats are rarely allergic to fish like tuna, why not make these simple two ingredient treats? They’re dairy, gluten, and grain free and are loaded with vitamins and minerals needed for your pet’s health. The recipe makes 50 servings that you can store in a cool place for more than 14 days. Perfect!

DIY Pumpkin Tuna Cat Treats From Animal Mama

If you’re looking to boost your cat’s immunity and tickle their taste buds, try making these pumpkin tuna cat treats.

The ingredient list is astonishingly healthy – even for you. You’ll need fresh tuna, carrot, pumpkin, egg, oat flour, catnip herb, and olive oil. If you don’t have tuna, choose any fish your feline baby likes. It takes about 30 minutes to make these cats treats, but you can cook them in bulk and store in the fridge for a week. Since these cat treats are a bit calorie-dense, don’t forget about moderation and make sure they get enough access to clean water too.

Homemade Blueberry Chicken Cat Treats From Oh Honey Blog

Yes, you read that right. Blueberries aren’t for your morning granola bowl only, your kitty deserves some berry treat as well.

While the combination of blueberries and chicken sounds weird, it provides your cat with a myriad of essential nutrients. Not to mention how delicious these treats are – even the pickiest cat will ask for an extra treat. These blueberry chicken treats are grain free and are made from four all-natural ingredients. The best part is they take only 5 minutes to bake. A win-win recipe!

cat in wicker basket

Peanut Butter Cat Treats From Paw Posting

There are lots of human foods that are toxic to cats, but peanut butter isn’t one of them.

It’s okay to treat your beloved pet to a peanut butter treat every now and then. However, it’s best if you make your own peanut butter or at least find an organic version. Lots of store-bought peanut butters contain preservatives like sodium benzoate or benzoic acid that can be harmful to your cat’s digestive system.

Apart from peanut butter, the recipe features applesauce, quinoa and buckwheat flours, and baking soda. Ensure your cat isn’t allergic to any ingredient. The treats are easy to make and you can store them for several days.

Birthday Cake for Your Cat From Mommity

Although some people call crazy those who celebrate the birthdays of their pets, each pet deserves to have a cake on their special day.

Of course, this cake will be different from your regular birthday cake, yet your feline child will thank you. This birthday cake contains the key ingredient that your kitty might love – tuna. Actually, the recipe is versatile and you can swap the ingredients, yet the entire idea is awesome and the recipe instructions are clear and easy to follow.

The great news is, this tuna birthday cake is quick to make. It takes about 15 minutes to bake the cake and the prep time is about 5 minutes or less.

Grain-Free Homemade Cat Cookies From Oh Honey Blog

Any picky cat will munch on these fabulous grain-free chewy chip cookies.

At first glance, they look like peanut butter cookies topped with chocolate chunks, however, these cookies aren’t for you. You will need about 5 minutes of baking time to prepare these chewy chip cookies and a bit of mixing and stirring. On a lazy weekend, when you will want to treat your family to some homemade cookies, don’t forget about your little feline bundle of joy. Just watch out as your cat can swallow them all. Moderation is still important.

Homemade Organic Spinach and Chicken Cat Treats From Popsugar

This crunchy treat is over-brimming with nutrients and taste fabulously delicious.

Spinach is rich in B vitamins, dietary fiber, potassium, calcium, iron, manganese, magnesium, vitamin K, vitamin C, and vitamin A, among the other nutrients. These treats also contain organic catnip, so your picky fur baby will certainly eat them with a huge pleasure. The recipe is versatile so you can use fish instead of chicken in case your cat has any allergic reactions to this meat.

Homemade Tuna and Cheddar Cat Treats From Building Our Story

If your cat is anything like you and it loves everything cheesy, then this homemade tuna and cheddar treats are a wonderful snack option.

While these treats are a bit fatty, it’s vital to feed your cat in moderation. The original recipe features a vegetable oil on the ingredient list, so if your fur baby is prone to weight gain, it’s better to skip it.


Here you have it! The list of some of the best and easiest homemade cat treats for picky cats that you can make regardless of your cooking and baking skills and busy schedules. So pick the one treat today and head to the kitchen right now.

Sharing is caring!

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.